Board of Trustees of the St. Helena Public Library

 

Minutes of the Meeting of April 14, 2010

 

Present:  Robert Darter, Susan Swan and Lynda Burton.   Also present were Kelly Wheaton from the Friend's, Leslie Stanton, acting director and Jennifer Baker, library director. 

 

The minutes from last month’s meeting were approved and consent items adopted.

 

Leslie gave a remodel update with a projected timeline for completion.

 

Lynda suggested doing formal thank you gifts for staff for all their hard work during the remodel. It was suggested that the Friends should be approached to fund a stipend for gifts. Lynda will manage purchase, organizing and distributing.

 

The Board discussed a proposal from staff to change hours. After much discussion of various pros and cons the issue was tabled to be brought up at a special meeting set for April 18 so that additional board members could participate in the decision making process.

 

Jennifer discussed the overall City Budget and the library’s proposed budget including General Fund, CLSA funds and more. Cuts have been made to the SNAP contract—since this contract is paid by both CLSA and GF funds, the cuts were applied to GF and CLSA remained flat. Additional cuts to the SNAP contract are expected because directors are reviewing database subscriptions and anticipate dropping several. EBSCO and several other key databases will be preserved however many are on the chopping block.

 

Linda Struve will retire at the end of May. The Board expressed concern that her position be filled since losing a full-time person would mean having to reduce library hours significantly. Jennifer reported that she had already spoken with Mary Neilan about filling the position and is making arrangements.

 

JuneFest was discussed. Lynda is working with the Foundation and Robyn Orsini to facilitate the event as an Open House. Board members were asked to volunteer to be available for the event. Rather than have tours, it is planned to have people stationed at various service points within the library to show off the new features of the remodel as people explore. The Friends plan to hold a book donation drive at the event to replenish stock.

 

Kelly Wheaton gave a brief report of the Friends’ most recent meeting.

 

There was no report from Wine Library or Historical Society.

 

The Foundation now has seven directors. They have hired a finance manager and are working to create appropriate publicity materials.

 

The meeting adjourned at 6:20pm.

 

Leslie Stanton, recording secretary

 

 

Board of Trustees of the St. Helena Public Library

 

Minutes of the Special Meeting of April 18, 2010

 

The meeting was called to order at 3:30pm. Present:  Robert Darter, Susan Swan, Bonnie Long and Lynda Burton.   Also present Leslie Stanton, acting director and Jennifer Baker, library director. 

 

This meeting was called specifically to discuss the issue of changing library hours.

 

Jennifer presented a report to the Board members explaining the reasons why changing hours was being considered at this time.

 

Several different options were considered and reviewed taking into account patron usage patterns, staff availability, programming standards, and possible budget changes. The following proposal was agreed to be the best scenario to address all these variables:

 

Tuesday, Wednesday & Thursday 10-9

Friday, Saturday, Sunday, & Monday 2-6

A total of 49 hours per week.

Library staff unanimously supported this change in schedule.

 

This schedule maintains the same number of weekday morning hours and adds an additional evening during the week. The shortened hours on Friday-Monday are better suited to patrons’ current use of the library and also allows for more flexible staffing.

 

Since Sue Michul left the library in January 2009 and her position was not filled, the library has been perpetually short-staffed. The new schedule will alleviate much of this stress. The shortened hours on Mondays and Friday will also allow fulltime staff to devote their full attention to projects and technical work when the library is not open to the public.

 

Additional benefits of the proposed schedule include a more simplified structure that will be easier to remember and advertise while maintaining a seven day a week schedule.

 

In their discussion of this proposal, the Trustees expressed concern over public perception of a reduction in hours, even one as slight as three hours a week. Although there have been no recent or new cuts to library staff, this change in schedule is the result of the cuts made in January 2009.

 

In their motion to approve the change to library hours, the Trustees clarified that maintaining current staffing levels is critical to the success of any seven day schedule. This includes being able to replace a fulltime employee who has announced intentions to retire at the end of May. The proposed schedule of 49 hours a week has many benefits; however, it is the maximum that library staff can reasonably maintain without a continuous negative impact on service levels. Library staff and the Trustees wish to be very clear that any further reductions in staffing would necessitate drastic changes to library hours and services, including, but not limited to, closing the library one or more days a week. The Trustees instructed Jennifer to be very clear on these points in her report to City Council.

 

 

 

The meeting adjourned at 4:30pm.

 

Leslie Stanton, recording secretary